JERMAIN TAYLOR OR KELLY PAVLIK, WHO WINS AND HOW? - AN EXCLUSIVE BRC POLL

Boxers, writers, trainers and friends of boxing have their say...
 



 

 

 

 
 
 

BRC INNER CIRCLE...

George Elsasser: Personally I’m not all that convinced the Youngstown kid is ready to pull the proverbial rabbit out of the hat. Puncher’s chance one may argue; maybe, maybe not, since we haven’t as yet seen any cracks in the chin construction of Taylor in some 28 unbeaten outings.   pick here is Taylor via unanimous decision - that is, unless Kelly turns up a bleeder - then it’s late stanza TKO.  (Read more here ...)

Stephen Jones: It is one of the more anticipated fights at Super Middleweight in recent years. Jermain has failed to convince most of us since winning his titles, a lot of promise and often a lot of hot air.. Manny has made some differences to Jermain's outlook but he never sets the world alight due to failings down the final stretch of the championship rounds.
Pavlik has been a sleeper for a long time and against Miranda he woke us all up plenty with a creative and dominant performance. Unfortunately I think Taylor will remain victorious, still failing to convince in a close one on points. Pavlik is very good but so is Jermain. Not great but still a Champion..   Jermain Taylor Pts 12..   probably Unanimously.. 

Oleg Bershadsky: This fight may actually be the strange case where a tested champion has more to prove than the challenger. Taylor has some impressive wins on his record, most notably against Bernard Hopkins and Cory Spinks. Yet his is the type of success that raises more questions, largely do to the controversial nature of his wins. The controversial draw with Winky Wright only adds to the doubts surrounding Taylor’s ability. (Read more here...)

Chris Ackerman: Taylor mirrors the effort and approach of his opposition...to do that and best or at least match masters of the game says something.  There used to be a fire in him, maybe a guy who brings it will make him rise to the occasion.  If he can't beat Pavlik, what does that say about those guys?  What I want to see Saturday night is the emergence of a champion... if it's Kelly, cool.  If it's Taylor, cool.  But questions about both guys will be answered, and that will not be thanks to JT, but to KP who is a lot more fan friendly in style than his opponent.   (Read more here...)

Ed Ludwig: Jermain Taylor’s reign as champion has been less than stellar thus far and part of it may be contributed to the quality of opposition he has faced. Memories of disputed victories over Bernard Hopkins have not been erased from peoples minds. Taylor has done enough to win but at the same time nothing has been decisive that get boxing fans talking.
Kelly Pavlik has a lot of fans talking and deservedly so after his thrashing of Edison Miranda. He will make Taylor fight and he is a serious threat to hand the former Olympian his first loss. This comes down to skill, heart and who wants it more and after it’s all said and done I see Kelly Pavlik raising his hands in victory by an eleventh round stoppage.

Martin Wade: I like Taylor and I'm sticking with him. I think Pavlik will force JT into the boxer envelope which was the thing that gave us high hopes about him. Manny Steward will correct the going backwards flaw and have Jermain circling the Youngstown slugger. It will be interesting early but Taylor's been in too many big fights to fold in rounds 8-12.

Frank Gonzalez Jr./Sharkie's Machine: Taylor does deserve credit for being a tough man to fight but his lack of 'quality' boxing skills might be the difference in this one. Pavlik is strong and exhibits very credible boxing prowess. If he catches Taylor during one of the brawling exchanges, it could be lights out.  
Pavlik has made his mark but beating Edison Miranda alone does not make a champion. Pavlik has a lot less experience against top fighters than does Jermain. Other than Miranda, who has Pavlik beaten? Zertuche? Bronco McKart?? 
Let us not forget that Taylor beat B. Hop TWICE...mostly on spunk and being busier.  It's going to be a good fight. A defining fight. I like Pavlik to win but scientific accounting doesn't support that pick.
Taylor is underrated and deservedly so after way smaller puffed up welter weight Cory Spinks took him the distance. Pavlik may be overrated after beating an undisciplined Edison Miranda. 
I have to go with Pavlik by decision...a beat down decision. But to quote Donald Rumsfeld, "Who knows?" 

Rizwaan Zahid: I think both fighters have a lot to prove in this fight.  Coming off a string of narrow victories along with a draw against Winky Wright, Jermain needs to prove that he's the undisputed middleweight champion for a reason.  Kelly, however, has to show that he is not just hype.  Many have simply judged him based on his fight with Miranda. (Read more here...)

Jim Amato: I think Kelly is going to have a lot of trouble with Taylor's speed and movement. Pavlik likes to go to the body though and he does it very well. Hopefully as the fight wears on this will slow Taylor down. (Read more here...)

Elisa Harrison: Who do I think will win tonight? I am going to make a daring prediction but first let me tell you why. I believe that HUNGER is a great  motivator  and in this fight, the hunger belongs to... (Read more here...)


BRC's FRIENDS...

This is what we call in the boxing business a pick 'em fight!! The reason I call this fight a pick 'em fight is, you have Taylor who in my opinion has not looked good in his last several fights, and who needs to look great in this fight!!! Pavlik, on the other hand is hungry, determined, and stays in great condition! Taylor has a problem staying focused throughout a fight, and that was evident when he fought Spinks... Taylor was not listening or could not do what was asked of him by Emanuel Steward! Both are aggressive boxers! On paper, this should be a great boxing match!!
I wish both gladiators the best of luck, and we wish no one gets hurts!
Howard Davis
1976 Olympic Champion!

This is honestly a pick 'em fight. I do like and I think we all love the desire and stick to it ness of Pavlik. Reminds me of the days of Gene Fullmer's old fights, (as I've seen in films), but I  can't knock the champion quite yet, the opposition that this man has faced is outstanding. I'm at a lost for words, do I go with grit and hunger, or do I go with determination and ferocity? And I say ferocity, because Taylor wants to prove he's a champion and a fighting champion. If you twisted my arm I would say Taylor in an outstanding fight.
Steve Forbes
Former IBF jr. lightweight champion
Contender Season 2 finalist

DRAW! LOL
John Duddy
Irish Ropes Promotions

Pavlik. Decision
Paulie Ayala

If I had to choose I would go with Kelly Pavlik. I think that he will win by knockout in the middle to late rounds. I think that he is hungrier and will seize the moment!
Kili-Scott

Taylor by stoppage
Edner Cherry, NABF lightweight champion

I think Pavlik is going to do it.
Chevelle Hallback, IBA International jr. lightweight champion

I think this will be a great fight.  Even though Taylor has looked horrible in his last couple of outings I still believe he is the better, more experienced fighter and will stop Pavlik in 10 rounds.  Sure Pavlik destroyed Edison Miranda, but he beat a slow fighter who's easy to hit.  Also, if you look at the list of guys Miranda has beaten, it's not that impressive.  Sure he stopped Howard Eastman and Willie Gibbs, but who have those guys beaten since?  Allan Green?  He almost faced the same fate against Colin McCarthy.  Pavlik has looked impressive, and one can't question his punching power, but he's entering the big leagues now, and I don't think Taylor, facing adversity now because of his lackluster performances, will squander the opportunity to silence his critics and cement himself as one of the very best in the sport.
Jermain Taylor TKO 10 Kelly Pavlik
Armando Alvarez
Producer, Telemundo

Taylor has been truly dedicated in training camp and is focused on making an example of Pavlik. Kelly is Taylor made style wise for Jermain coming forward as a puncher brawler. If Taylor can stop backing to the ropes when his opponent attempts to advance and fights more in the way he did against Hopkins working the angles and stepping around Pavlik creating openings then I feel he can wear Kelly down and finish him in the later rounds.  Taylor by TKO in 10th.
Keith Terceira, Co-Host TalkinBoxing with Billy C
www.TPSRadio.net

TAYLOR should win.
Prof. Roberto Quesada, trainer
www.rqboxinginstitute.com

Taylor by a very, very close decision...
RUSTY

I think it will a very tactical fight with both guys showing a lot of respect for each other if it does not end early I see a Draw....
J.D. Brown
Manager William Joppy

Tremendous fight between the undisputed champion and the legitimate #1 contender. Jermain Taylor must be on his best to stave off the two fisted power punching Kelly Pavlik, and he will. Jermain Taylor retains his middleweight crown via unanimous decision.
Mike Indri
Retired Boxers Foundation

I like Pavlik in this one. KO
Jackie Kallen

I think I'll go with Taylor this time. Don't know why, just a hunch.
Phil Weinstein
Amateur Coach

Kelly Pavlik should beat Jermain Taylor by knockout within 10 rounds. Pavlik is a tougher fighter and always shows determination to win. He is a good boxer and has a devastating power. 
Oscar Borrás
20 de Mayo Publication

Taylor by KO 5, perhaps even earlier. While it is true Taylor hasn't looked that well in his last few fights, I feel that he will demonstrate more ability and punching power, than in all his previous fights. Pavlik is a very strong young man, his record clearly states that, but fighting Taylor is a new thing for him, a level at which he has never performed in. Taylor is no Miranda.
Luis Ramos
Amateur Coach

I think that Taylor will rise to the occasion and make Pavlik pay for coming forward in the early rounds. Jermain should then be able to keep the action at a slower pace and on the outside where his precision jab can set up combinations and catch Kelly with stinging counters en route to a unanimous decision win.
Curtis McCormick
McCormickMediaGroup.com

Taylor wins and it goes the distance. 
Jen Childers Campbell
Childers Boxing Promotions LLC

I know that Taylor has not been up to par since changing trainers but I still believe in his talent... his latest performances have brought some criticism but he will get the decision. 
Elmo Adolph

I think that Kelly Pavlik will win by TKO in the 9th round.
Jake Hall
Indiana Boxing Commissioner

Pavlik by late KO 9th or 10th round, I think Taylor will fade as the fight goes on, he was not impressive on his last outing. Pavlik will mount a constant attack on him
Boxing Official who wishes to remain anonymous

Pavlik by 7th round KO or Taylor by decision.
Damon Feldman
KO Fightz

9-27-2007


Brought to you by Saratogamist copyright 2001-2008