HOW THEY PICK 'EM: HATTON vs PACQUIAO - WHO WINS AND HOW?

 

BRC Writers Exclusive Hatton- Pacquiao Poll

 

 

  

 
 

 

HATTON THE PICK... IF THEY LET HIM FIGHT... by George Elsasser
I’ll pass on the hype that arrived long before the big Vegas shootout - right or wrong the choice is Ricky Hatton - supporting my pick is his recovering from the Mayweather TKO12 loss, with wins over Malignaggi and Lazcano. Hints of smoldering flames still in the Manchester hit-man body.  
Pacquiao will engage early on - but the change from successful power, sling-shot artist with the left hand, will not hold up over a likely grueling battle of attrition with Hatton over the long run.


 
ALADDIN FREEMAN: Poor Ricky Hatton is an after thought at this fight, if you also consider that Manny Pacquiao is being vastly overrated in this fight after beating up an old Oscar de la Hoya you can understand why.
 
It's true that Manny has the speed advantage, probably the confidence as well and maybe even the overall skills. Still, I think 140 lbs. is Hatton's best weight and he's naturally the bigger man.
 
I don't think he has Marquez's overall skills who gave Pacquiao fits but I'm going to go against the grain and pick Hatton to win by late stoppage. I think/hope that because Hatton fought a faster fighter in Floyd Mayweather Jr., that  will help him stay in this fight vs. Pacquiao.
 
So, for all of the above reasons, I say put me down for Hatton KO 11.
 

CHRIS ROBINSON: I have to go with Pacquiao on this one, just because he has a lot of momentum going and it sounds like he's in great shape. Hatton brings some things to the table that Pac hasn't seen, but Ricky hasn't impressed in a performance in a long time. Definitely looking forward to this one but I have to give Pac an edge...


STEPHEN JONES: I am struggling with this one , the facts are that Hatton has only ever failed to deliver at Welterweight.. and this is at his ideal division. Pac is very strong at this weight too, his speed was not effected at all against Oscar de la Hoya after a weight jump and he was amazing even if Oscar was slightly damaged goods.

Pac has been hurt in fights before , more often than not to the body which if allowed to do so , is Hatton's game.. If Ricky plays out a very solid game plan and puts massive pressure on Pac to the body throughout a long fight, he could break Pac down, but Pac is one of the greatest fighters I have ever seen lace on gloves, nothing in this fight is simple, and my decision has become hard for me to conclude..  Manny has strengths and weaknesses that can play into Hatton's hands and if Ricky can have one final great night that can supersede the Mayweather bout I see no reason why Hatton can't come through victorious, Both men are in absolutely unbelievable condition and it takes me to those Leonard v Benitez type fights where they both compliment each other...  I am lost for words...   

Hatton by a late stoppage via body shots...   Or Pacquiao decision in a brutal fight with high drama.. It's a hung verdict here..

I am getting splinters on my ass for sitting on the fence...


RICKY RAY TAYLOR: OUT ON A LIMB ~
As always, Hatton's intensity will be feverish & straight-forward, Pacquiao will immediately roll into COUNTER-PUNCH mode and remain there throughout the fight. Hatton will win the early rounds with his in-your-face aggression & primarily due to sheer strength, Pacquiao will land the cleaner shots in the early half of the fight - yet they will be fewer as the bout progresses and as Hatton closes the "hard-earned" distance which Pacman needs to land them, in the second half of the fight, as each guy closes in on the other. The ref will finally earn his money as he works to separate the two from clinching, Pac will win a few of the middle rounds & consistently land the cleaner shots as Hatton bullies him around the ring with strength, by round 10 Pacman fades quickly, Hatton turns it up and stops him in the championship rounds.

www.BoxerDRILLZ.com
Hotline: 917 758-0058
 

MARK URBAN: Being a Brit I am tempted to sway towards a Ricky Hatton victory however one thing concerns me. Anyone who has watched Ricky Hatton's older fights will notice that his face has a tendency to cut up quite badly, and with the sheer amounts of punches that Pacquaio will be throwing, this is a genuine concern. Hatton let the occasion get the better of him during the Mayweather fight and abandoned his game plan for sheer brute force and emotion and subsequently paid the price. I have a feeling he will be much better prepared this time around and will test Pacquiao with some serious body blows and aggression. Hatton has always suggested that Light Welterweight is his preferred weight and don't forget he is still undefeated at this weight class. This has the making of a hall of fame fight with both going at it from the first bell and throw into the mix two of the best trainers in the sport today and this is a must see fight. I will go Hatton by KO in round 8. 


MARTIN WADE: I heard that Floyd “Joy” Mayweather Sr. thinks that the Pacman delivers his punches like an amateur. And? That Ali guy pulled his head back, Roy Jones couldn’t spell jab, and Joe Calzaghe slaps when he flurries. What Manny Pacquiao will prove to Ricky Hatton is what his trainer's son proved, when you're gifted there ain't much anybody can do about your “flaws.” I see Big Floyd being comfortable enough to crack the whip and keep Ricky from jumping in with no jab early. Ricky’s pressure and rough house tactics will keep it interesting early but Manny’s “late speed” will turn the tide. Manny’s straight lefts will remain blistering fast long after Ricky has slowed down and it will lead to a late stoppage on cuts.  Pacquiao by late round TKO.


LUIS RAMOS: Hatton by 9th round KO or TKO


 

BILL STEPHENS: The pride of the Philippines meets the people's champion in Vegas style. The bright lights of Sin City will bring out the finest for this battle of supremacy between countries. Two nations collide in a fast and furious rage between champions. A Hitman never stops until the mission is completed. The fighting pride of the Philippines has become a fan favorite after the heavily hyped De la Hoya match in December. Hatton brings his own fans, equipped with a horn section to cheer the slugger on as he bangs away at his opponent.

The Hitman is rugged and tough, Manchester style. Pacquiao should continue his aggressive style of fighting which will not be enough for a knockdown. The two champions will be bangen and clangen until the final bell rings at the end of the twelfth. Both fighters will be ready to go fifteen or all night with it being Vegas. Pacquiao will ultimately get the nod at the end of this great match up of Champions. The ultimate winner in the end will be Oscar de la Hoya  and Golden Boy Promotions.       


 

DARREN YATES: Manny Pacquiao  certainly seems to be everyone’s favourite going into this fight based on the sheer dominance he displayed in defeating Oscar de la Hoya. I believe that whilst the Pacman put on an excellent showing, he defeated a weight-drained De la Hoya who seemed to be a shadow of his former self. The strength of Pacquiao’s win over Oscar needs to be kept in perspective as Oscar took the Pacman's punches quite well, in his prime Oscar would have avoided at least half of the punches landed and landed significantly more. Oscar didn’t have the reflexes or legs to do so this time. Ricky Hatton will be a different story as he is in his prime, very fit and believe it or not, can take a very good punch and fire back.  

I see Hatton taking a few good shots from the Pacman and then working his way on the inside where he will smother the Pacman and use his greater strength to wrestle and work in close, to physically drain Manny down. I believe this will be Manny Pacquiao’s toughest opponent since Juan Manuel Marquez, but in a different style. I’m going out on a limb here and predict that Freddie Roach will retire the Pacman at the start of the 11th round after a tough, in the trenches battle that will not be as exciting as everyone is expecting.


GARY TODD: I like Pacquiao to wear down Hatton , to finally take him out with uppercuts , late in the fight. Pacquiao will need to weather an aggressive and highly charged Hatton for the first 7  rounds. if Pacquiao can box using his tremendous lateral southpaw stance, doubling up on the jab, quickly following with fast, accurate combinations, he should take Hatton's heart and mind, to win by TKO in the 10th round.

My only concern for the fight is the high possibility of either fighter being cut. head clashes could well be a major influence in this mega fight. let's hope not.



JEFF MAYWEATHER:
I pick Hatton because I think he is the bigger and more rugged fighter. I feel that the Pacquiao victory over Oscar de la Hoya is a little tainted, even by his own trainer's  admission Freddie Roach. During his interview for the HBO 24/7 series, when Roach saw the fresh blood coming from the tracks of De la Hoya's arms he realized that Oscar's team was trying to re-hydrate him through an I.V., (intravenously), letting the boxing world know that Oscar was just a shell of his former self and came into the ring as a dead man walking.

I don't think Ricky Hatton will come in drained and flat. Hatton comes from as high as 170 and has mastered making this weight throughout his career, having suffered  only loss and that was at welterweight, and even in that fight through five rounds, Ricky gave Floyd Mayweather Jr. all he could handle and then some. Floyd is a great fighter and was able to make the necessary adjustments to emerge victorious. Manny is a hell of a fighter but he's not a Floyd Mayweather Jr., style wise nor talent wise. Still I think it will be an extremely tough fight from both sides. Yet, I give the edge to Hatton...

 

SCOTT SANDERS: Everyone will correctly point out that De La Hoya was a shell of himself when Manny beat him last December.  While this is true, Pacquaio didn't just beat him, he owned him.  It was an impressive performance in any context.  No doubt that a well trained Hatton will be a much tougher test. My thinking is that Pacquiao's blazing hand speed will end up being too much for Ricky. 

I'm predicting that a competitive fight becomes more and more one sided until the brave Hatton is stopped on cuts or by his own corner in the late rounds.
 


FRANK GONZALEZ JR. : Hatton vs Pacquaio will pit the naturally smaller Pacman against the naturally larger Hatton. Unlike Oscar de la Hoya, Hatton is not past his prime and ready for the glue factory. How Pacman is suddenly labeled "the best pound for pound" fighter in boxing seems to have been borne out of his win over a washed up Oscar. Many intelligent fans know that the whole p4p thing is little more than a marketing ploy to sell Pay-Per-Views.  
 
 
Hatton always enters the ring in top condition and has legendary stamina. Hatton has built his career with a smothering style of fighting, punching like a windmill and then holding often after releasing his offense. With his new trainer Floyd Mayweather Senior, who is a great defensive minded trainer, expect Hatton to surprise people with a smoother version of his old self.
 
Pacquaio is trained by Freddy Roach, a legend in his own league. Pacman is always in great shape and as he's aged, his boxing techniques are more refined. Having fought the great Juan Manuel Marquez twice, Pacman has tremendous experience in dealing with adversity. (Friendly Judges help too)  Pacman is a bigger puncher and if Ricky is careless, Manny is capable of knocking him out. Not because he's so big a puncher at 140 but because his technique is compatible with his speed, which in itself generates big power.
 
Both guys are warriors and both will come to win. Both men have surely watched enough tape on the other to have an idea of what will work best in the scenarios that will present themselves during the battle. Pacquaio doesn't like to be swarmed, and Ricky is all about smothering his opponents. Hatton has a poor history against good technical boxers, like Mayweather Jr. and Collazo. Pacquaio is the sharper puncher.
 
My prediction: A great fight.


ED LUDWIG: Manny Pacquiao by TKO in round nine. I see the first three or four rounds to be somewhat back and forth with both fighters looking to get an idea of what the other has to offer. As the rounds progress I see Pacquiao turning it up a notch and after a couple of knockdowns in round nine Ricky Hatton will be saved by the referee and Pacman will have his arms raised.


HILARIO FLORES: Manny Pacquiao by decision.  Too fast & too many punches for Hatton.


ELISA HARRISON: I am almost afraid to get hyped up about what should be an exciting and action packed encounter, because so often in our sport we expect a lot and end up getting very little. It is hard to imagine that two proven warriors like Hatton and Pacquiao would disappoint the fans; however, there are others who can influence the outcome of fights and they don't always do their jobs properly. I still haven't figured out how a fighter can knock out his opponent and still lose the fight, or how a referee can stop a fight and re-start it two minutes later, just to mention two of the most blatant examples that come to mind.

Doom and gloom aside, I know Ricky and Manny will go at it from the opening bell and I can't imagine the fight going the distance. It's going to boil down to stamina and conditioning, and even in those departments the respective coaches have prepared their men to go the distance and then some. So, who wins? I am going to give the edge to Hatton, who judging by what I've seen on HBO's 24/7 segments, seems to be relaxed, enjoying his camp, and improved in many aspects. Hatton, under the tutelage of Floyd Joy Mayweather can prove to be to a bit more than Pacquiao can chew. Then again....

 

Questions? Comments? Post them in BRC's new Message Board...


 

 

4-23-2009
 

 

 

 

Brought to you by Saratogamist copyright 2001-2009