MAYWEATHER - HATTON: WHO WINS? AN EXCLUSIVE BRC POLL

 



 

 

 
 
 
 

BRC'S INNER CIRCLE...

ALADDIN FREEMAN - I think Floyd wins on points; there is a reason he brought Hatton up to welterweight. The last time Hatton was at 147 lbs. he should have lost to Luis Collazo, who, I also may add was never considered a big puncher but had Ricky hurt badly a couple times in the fight.

Mayweather Jr. has to start faster in this fight than he has in his past two. If he allows Hatton to get it going early then it could be a long, rough night for him. However, if he uses his legs then it can be an easier fight for him.

Floyd has shown signs of slowing down and now hearing him publicly say that he is wearing down only leads me to believe that there is some self doubt in his mind maybe not about this fight but about his boxing career. 


GEORGE ELSASSER - Mayweather by unanimous decision or late stoppage via cuts.  Hatton expected to make it interesting over stanzas one thru six - but the slick, cool, calm, collected in demeanor Mayweather, will pick and choose to victory.


For more on Geo's pick, please go here


KENNY PERRAULT - I'm having a tough time picking a winner for the upcoming Mayweather Hatton fight. I can see the fight going a lot of ways for both men. But in the end I'm going with Hatton. I don't think Mayweather has the power to hurt him and Hatton isn't afraid to take a punch. So my prediction is Hatton wears down Mayweather for a late round knockout.


STEPHEN JONES - This has to be one of the most highly anticipated events that I can remember between a British fighter and a P4P claimant in my years in the game.. The last one of note that I really can remember is either Bruno- Tyson I or Honeyghan v Curry. Without a doubt Floyd has to be where the smart money is at, and if he fights in accordance to his potential and engages his brain he would fight his own game and win a fairly solid decision ala movement and fast hands ..  BUT! That is in a perfect world.

 

In a perfect world he would have Jeff in his corner and staying focused and humble, listening to good advice and not getting involved. The problem being, Ricky is the kind of pressure fighter who can get to you if you stand in front of him and any show of machismo from Floyd in the middle rounds, playing up to the crowd to satisfy his ego, may be where the mistakes will happen. If that be the case, Ricky may have been a little overlooked and in a physical fight of any kind Hatton will have won the war of tactics and he will take Floyd to places that he hasn't been to before. Corley showed us how Mayweather can be hit and if Ricky gets the chances that 'Chop Chop' got, it could spell Floyd's demise and he wont yet have realized it. 

 

Hatton has the potential to win this fight inside the distance if the fight suits him, and if Floyd is stupid enough to fight Hatton's type of fight trust me, he will go the same way as Castillo. The bottom line: I can't yet split these two and will sit right on the fence because it's my birthday come Saturday and I am allowed to. God bless.. It's going to be a magnificent fight..


TOM DICKEY - It's hard to bet against Pretty Boy, and I'm not going to be the one to do it. I think Hatton will keep the pressure constantly on Floyd, making it a better fight than Mayweather vs Oscar de la Hoya. But, Floyd will be able to outbox and out quick the aggressive Hatton. I just don't think Hatton's seen anything like Floyd, and as much as I would like to see him win, I just can't see it happening.

Floyd by unanimous decision.


OLEG BERSHADSKY - The clear media favorite in this fight, not surprisingly, is Floyd Mayweather Jr. He is the best pound for pound boxer in the sport, with superior hand speed, and natural talent rivaled by no one. If these advantages weren’t enough, he will also be fighting on his home turf of Las Vegas, Nevada, and not having to adjust to the time difference may be another advantage he has over Hatton. So does Hatton even stand a chance with all this stacked against him? How can he hope to beat a better boxer with tremendous defense, away from his home town of Manchester?

For answers to these questions, read here


CHRIS ACKERMAN - I like Ricky Hatton's personality.  He's funny and seems like a genuinely nice guy.  Too bad he is going to get beat up on Saturday night.  There is a real buzz in the air about this fight and the reason is because Hatton is seen as potentially a stylistic nightmare for PBF.  He is gritty, active, tireless, presses the action, rough and quicker than he gets credit for.  I have even heard a lot of talk recently about Floyd's first clash with Jose Luis Castillo and how that is somehow a blueprint or template on how to beat the number one pound for pound fighter in the world.  That fight is ancient history and, in my opinion, about as relevant as Floyd's fight with Gatti.  My prediction for this one falls roughly in between those two.  I think people just want to see Floyd lose to a good fella like Ricky.  He won't though. 

The beauty part is that no matter what happens, we are going to see Floyd fight because Ricky Hatton is going to force him into it.  No rest, no respite...he'll ask Floyd if he can handle the pressure.  Floyd will reply in the affirmative in what I suspect will be a performance that will have more than a few dazzling moments.  The other beauty part is all the wild cards:  maybe Floyd has been distracted of late (fat chance), maybe Hatton will get cut and fight even more aggressively, maybe Floyd's hands are hurt again (pffft...), maybe Ricky has gotten in Floyd's head.  In the end, I can't help but believing Mayweather is gonna take Hatton's virginity...but I can't decide if I hope I'm wrong.

Mayweather UD or late on cuts.


ED LUDWIG - The dancing outside the ring is over for Floyd Mayweather and now it’s back to business. I do not expect this fight to be a thriller by any means as Ricky Hatton is tailor made for Mayweather.

Hatton will come out strong and rush Mayweather for the first few rounds and then he will be gassed and it will be downhill for him after that. Mayweather is as close to the complete package as you are going to get and Hatton is more one dimensional than anything.

I feel counter punching will be the key as Hatton will be the one forcing the fight and taking the initiative but Mayweather is just too smart to trade and put himself at risk. Counter punching will be the key for Mayweather. For every shot Hatton lands Mayweather will answer back with two or three shots of his own.

Mayweather wins by a very lopsided unanimous decision.


DARREN YATES - I haven’t had much luck picking winners recently. I picked Kessler to beat Calzaghe and Mosley to beat Cotto. I am picking Mayweather to beat Hatton easily by 12 round decision in what will be more than likely another boring display of brilliance from Floyd, totally undeserving of the money he is paid. If the fight is exciting, it will be because of Ricky Hatton’s efforts. I am hoping my shocking form of picking winners in recent times continues as there has NOT been a fighter since Roy Jones Jnr. who so desperately needs to be humbled by a loss as Floyd Mayweather Jnr. does.

I couldn’t see Ricky Hatton being able to beat Kostya Tszyu, I hope the Hitman surprises me again! 


FRANK GONZALEZ JR. - I think Ricky Hatton can win this fight by employing the kind of pressure he applied on Kostya Tszyu. If he keeps the pressure on continuously and forces Floyd to fight Ricky's style of brawl instead of Floyd's type of box and move fight, it could end with Hatton winning by late TKO.

Mayweather will score points during exchanges and has sneaky power that can be dangerous, if he can land that triple left hook. But Floyd has always had hand problems and Ricky looks to be in the kind of shape that he will happily let Floyd land three to deliver one.

Hatton is unquestionably athletic and his level of activity could frustrate Mayweather enough to put him in a position he doesn't want to be in. The common wisdom might be that Floyd will win because of his superior boxing skills and defense, but I like Hatton to win this fight on sheer aggression and intelligent use of his fight mentality. He has the ability to keep Floyd very busy round after round until late in the fight. If Ricky can handle what power Floyd does possess, he will win the fight. There will be exchanges and Floyd will get hit. Who has the chin will win. 

As a fan, I like certain fighters, respect others and outright can't stand some. I like Hatton, he's a good natured kid who brings respect to the sport. Floyd gives a poor impression of himself with his worship of material things and constant bragging. I've seen that type get humbled before.

But who knows what will happen? That's why they fight the fights. Speculation has limited value in fights between legitimate champions.


DAVID L. ROSS - Too much speed, although Hatton’s grit will not allow him to falter too much.  I see it going the distance with Mayweather winning via unanimous decision.

Mayweather via decision.


RIZWAAN ZAHID - Mayweather vs Hatton is probably the biggest fight of this year for many boxing fans.  Neither fighter has ever been defeated and both have been dominating nearly all of their opponents in the recent years.  Now... on to the prediction.
 
Mayweather is a slow starter and expect the first six rounds to be close, if not in favour of Hatton.  Hatton's key will have to be going to the body and as we have seen in the 24/7 clips, he has been practicing that.  However, Mayweather has experience with people trying to target his body but his precision and speed is overwhelming.  Mayweather does not throw a lot of punches per round.  He may only throw 45, but he usually lands 25 of those.  Although Mayweather has a jab he doesn't often use it, in this fight he may.
 
After the first six, expect Mayweather's lead right hand to become a big factor, especially when countering a left hook by Hatton.  In the end, Mayweather's skills and speed will help him a lot down the stretch.
 
Mayweather UD 12, in a close but deserved decision.


MARTIN WADE - I like Mayweather by embarrassing SD.

Floyd isn’t fighting a part-time celebrity, a wannabe rapper, neither a journeyman nor an action figure. Ricky Hatton is a FIGHTER with underrated speed and footwork. Floyd actually surprised De La Hoya with his strength but let’s face it if Ricky comes in light (142-143 lbs) he can be a BULL. Both of these guys are the elite at 140 lbs, both of them are too small for real welterweights and it will be more entertaining than most think. Mark my words, Floyd will tweak that right hand on the first guy in years to make him use it. Ricky will parlay the moral victory into a bout with Oscar and Floyd may take his traveling villain act to MSG in June 2008.


JOCELYN SAURINI - Okay, I'm a girl, and that means that in addition to watching boxing, I also watched every single episode of "Dancing With the Stars," including all the ones that Floyd Mayweather was on. It's this simple; in a big fight where many things seem equal, I'll always go with the fighter who seems more focused on the fight. On Tuesday night, Mayweather was in LA to appear on the "Dancing With the Stars" finale show. On Wednesday, he came back to Vegas to train, but to train in front of media, which we all know isn't real training. I think the fight could honestly be a toss up, and in a situation like that, I'll take the fighter who didn't spend the week before the fight putting on his best LA sunglasses and expensive shirt and playing it up for the cameras on national TV.  But what it tells me when a fighter is doing a reality TV show while also preparing for a big fight is that the fighter is either a) bored, or b) unfocused, or c) both.

I take Hatton in a close one.


SCOTT SANDERS - People are making two mistakes regarding Ricky Hatton.  First they are assuming this match will be a replay of the Mayweather-Gatti fight.  There is no comparison between Gatti and Hatton.  Gatti started as a featherweight and when he fought Floyd he already had a lot of boxing mileage on him and nothing close to the speed and skills of Hatton.  The other mistake people are making is dismissing Ricky after seeing his fight against Luis Collazo at 147 lbs.  Hatton took that fight on short notice when he was training for a fight at 140.  Knowing he didn't have to make weight against an obscure opponent, Hatton eased off his training and underrated the gritty Collazo.  This time he has been pointing for Floyd for months now and will be a finely tuned 147 lbs on 12/8.


Of course Mayweather is miles better than Collazo.  However, he isn't a true welterweight, while Hatton has been at 140 since he was boxing as a teenager.  Mayweather has the blazing speed and an airtight defense, but styles make fights.  Ricky has the tenacity and conditioning to keep Floyd off his game and make him work harder than he wants to.

If I had to bet my life on this fight I'd probably go with Mayweather.  But if I'm getting odds I'll go with Hatton to win a hotly disputed fight that will trigger a huge rematch.  Put me down for Hatton by split decision.  


RICKY RAY TAYLOR www.BoxerDRILLZ.com - As much as I'd like ANY loudmouth in Boxing (or in any sport) to be STOPPED, I truly don't think it'll happen to Floyd any time soon.  I'm not one of the trumpeters leading the HATTON bandwagon.  For one thing we all must understand the vast difference in a fighter's arsenal that exists when he's backed by 15 to 20,000 screaming fans as compared to being backed by maybe a few hundred.  Keep in mind that I was probably as shocked as anyone to watch Kostya be steamrolled by Hatton. 

However, as Kostya spent a week in Manchester preparing for his showdown, I didn't have the opportunity to understand the full flavor of what was going down behind the scenes.  We can rest assure that the hungry BRITS taunted him at every corner planting seeds of doubt and utterances of defeat.  I didn't see them do it, neither did you or the bookies in Vegas but Kostya saw them and heard them and evidently listened to an entire country's confidence in their up and coming hero.  Have you ever been in a country where everyone knows you and basically wants you to die?

Bottom line, ask any rival soccer team - fighting in one's "hometown" cannot even begin to brush the magnitude of being swarmed by an entire country of crazed Brits while preparing for a sporting event.

With this in mind, let's understand a few intangibles about this match up:
-Hatton is fighting Floyd in VEGAS - Floyd's adopted hometown for the last few years.
-Hatton's last four fights: He beat up an "elderly" 60+ fight veteran Castillo, a young & untested Urango took him 12 rounds, another young & untested Collazo damn near beat him in 12 rounds and an overly hyped Maussa went 9 with him.
-Mayweather's last five:  Regardless of what fight Roth & Kaczmarek saw, I had him winning all but two rounds with Hoya, he made Baldomir look like a punching bag, he outclassed and out sped  lightening Zab Judah, and he put a severe whipping on Sharmba Mitchell five months after the Commissioner had to jump into the ring to resuscitate Gatti.
 
FINAL TAKE:  I really don't think I'll eat my words here but I am gonna go out on a limb and say that not only will Mayweather DESTROY Hatton, he'll knock him OUT within 6 rounds.


GARY TODD - I’m still going for a TKO for Hatton in the 7th round.

For more on Gary's pick, please click here


DAVID TYLER - Floyd Mayweather Jr. has the hand and foot speed of a young Ali.  Mayweather has mastered the art of throwing punches and using his foot speed to evade any returning punches from opponents.  Mayweather also uses his quick wit combined with insults to entice his opponents into wasting energy by going for the early knockout.  He has called Ricky Hatton a coward, cheater, Ricky Fatton (whatever that means), and a pussy, (I know what that means).

...All of these questions and more will be answered this Saturday, December 8th, in Las Vegas.  This fight could quite possibly make December 8th stand for something other than the anniversary of John Lennon’s murder.


HARDCHARGER  - Mayweather. Unanimous decision. Too much class and speed.


ELISA HARRISON - Who gave Ricky Hatton a chance against the mighty Kostya Tszyu? Who would have believed he'd make him quit on the stool? Not many people, right? Well, history seems to be repeating itself as not many people feel Hatton has what it takes to take down Mayweather Jr. once and for all.

I found it telling that Mayweather Jr. is already making excuses about his hands, his body breaking down, etc. (If he is having so many health issues perhaps he can bow out gracefully now, there is still time). Hatton has been fighting for as long as Floyd has and I haven't heard or read any excuses coming from him. Sorry, but I am not buying into Mayweather Jr.'s supremacy.

I think Hatton is being overlooked and underestimated, and there is going to be a price to be paid for that. I don't believe he is naive enough to leave the decision to the judges, either. Let's face it, hanky panky happens all too often in Las Vegas.

It is my belief that Hatton is going to lay it all on the line, and Mayweather is going to have to bring his A game plus a Louisville slugger to beat this kid.

Oh, and if Floyd Jr. thinks he is going to dance and pirouette his way around the ring tonight, he better think again. The fans are not going to go for it, they are not going to buy it, not this time around. Too much talking, too much fronting, too much posturing; he is going to have to live up to his own hype and in doing so, he will be stopped by a vicious, ruthless and powerful Ricky Hatton.

I can't wait.




OTHER BOXING EXPERTS...
 

I think Ricky Hatton is a great champion and fighter. He has beaten a lot of tough boxers including Kostya Tszyu. Floyd Mayweather is pound for pound the best fighter in boxing. I think the match will go the entire 12 rounds.

Floyd Mayweather can not knock out Hatton; the match will go to the judges score cards.

Mayweather by split decision. - NONITO 'THE FILIPINO FLASH' DONAIRE, IBF AND IBO Flyweight champion


Mayweather, unanimous decision - EDISON 'PANTERA' MIRANDA, super middleweight contender, www.panteraboxing.com


Mayweather by decision - ANDRE BERTO, NABF welterweight champion, WBC and IBF contender


Hatton stops him. - JOEY GILBERT, WBO NABO and WBC USNBC middleweight champion


I think Mayweather wins the fight by decision. He's fighting the same style of fighter like Carlos Baldomir. Except the only difference is Hatton is stronger and  a lot busier. Mayweather fights at his best against guys that pressure him. Hatton has a good chin and will make the fight exciting at times, but won't be able to handle Mayweather's speed and intelligence. Mayweather in my opinion pound for pound, the best! - RAUL 'EL DIAMANTE' MARQUEZ, former IBF light middleweight champion


Mayweather all the way! - AARON 'THE HAWK' PRYOR, 1996 International Boxing Hall of Fame Inductee, http://www.hawktime.com


Mayweather STOPS Hatton in  9th or 10th round because Hatton can't see out of his left eye! Too many combinations from Mayweather throughout the fight! Ricky becomes frustrated with Mayweather, begins to use DIRTY tactics! :-(
Ricky will be game; but, just TOO much speed and sharp shooting from Floyd!

Somehow Ricky's will and determination keeps him up on his feet. However, Hatton's corner throws in the towel and he's able to fight again! That's how I see the fight going.


Enough Said, enjoy the show! - DaVARRYL 'TOUCH OF SLEEP' WILLIAMSON, heavyweight contender


Mayweather... 12 round decision - JOHNATHON BANKS, WBO NABO cruiserweight champion, www.johnathonbanks.com


Mayweather wins, fight goes the distance. - PAULY AYALA, former WBA bantamweight champion


I gotta go with Mayweather just because the man is the pound for pound king. While people might not like his attitude and the way he talks about his opponents what no one can take away from him is his absolute skill, and his ability to break down his opponents, to dissect them like a surgeon, so I'm going with Floyd. I think it will be an excellent fight with Hatton really trying to force the issue, and possibly rattling the champion for a moment. But the hardest training pound for pound king will come back to pick Hatton apart and get the win. - STEVIE FORBES, former USBA and IBF super featherweight champion


Mayweather will win the fight. - DeMARCUS 'CHOP CHOP' CORLEY, former WBO light welterweight champion


As much as I want Hatton to win, I think Mayweather is unstoppable now at the top of his game. Floyd by majority or split decision! - VANES 'THE NIGHTMARE' MARTIROSYAN, undefeated light middleweight contender, www.VanesBoxing.com


Mayweather by a unanimous decision. I would like nothing more than to see Mayweather get a loss and a beat down, but I don't think it is in the cards. However, in boxing anything can happen and everybody is one punch away from getting knocked out. Floyd is just to fast and too smart to let Hatton ruffle his feathers. It is very possible Floyd even stops Hatton but most likely, he wins a unanimous decision. PETER 'SWEET PETE' FRISSINA, former WBO NABO and USBA  bantamweight champion


I like Hatton and his no nonsense approach to boxing, but if Mayweather does what he does best, which is box, I think Hatton gets frustrated and loses on points.  Keep the Faith. - ROSS PURITTY, former WBC International heavyweight champion


Easy work for Mayweather on Saturday - ASHLEY 'TREASURE' THEOPHANE, Global Boxing Council jr. welterweight champion


This is going to be a great fight.  Hatton has power and Mayweather has speed.  I think if Ricky catches him early--he has a chance to stop Floyd.  But I predict a decision.  Winner: Mayweather - JACKIE KALLEN


Mayweather vs. Hatton should be a very interesting fight. Both fighters are undefeated and both have proved their class in the ring. Hatton was fantastic against Kostya Tszyu and José Luis Castillo.

Mayweather, has been fantastic against everybody. He's the fighter pound-per-pound in the world today, therefore, "The Pretty Boy" should be the winner, probably by TKO in the later rounds. - OSCAR BORRAS, 20 de Mayo Spanish Newspaper 


Mayweather wins an easy unanimous decision. The only way anyone can beat Mayweather is to slow him down early, and you need either a lucky punch or a solid combination of speed and power to take the wind out of him. Mayweather can be beat, but it isn't easy as Hatton will find out. Of course if Ricky lands hard and early all bets are off, but I don't see that happening. - RUSTY RUBIN, Editor in Chief of Ringsports.com


I think it is a very competitive and close fight with Mayweather boxing and moving to a split decision. Hatton will be working to the body to try and slow Floyd, but to no avail. -  J.D. BROWN, William Joppy's manager


Floyd Mayweather should win an easy twelve round decision if he uses his superior speed and boxing skills. If Floyd wants to get into a war with Ricky, then anything could happen and we would get to see a good fight. - JAKE HALL, Indiana Boxing Commissioner


I know a lot of people have been bringing up all the ways that Hatton can and will win this fight. Many have talked about his relentless pressure, his awesome body punching and his will to win to go along with his dogged determination as factors in why they will pick him to defeat Mayweather. And while I believe that Hatton is a warrior and a very determined individual who always comes to fight and is probably much more skilled than most give him credit for I also believe that Floyd is one of those guys, like a Ray Leonard, who has all the tools and gifts at his disposal.

I have actually trained in the gym out in Las Vegas when he was also training and while I am sure Hatton works hard in the gym I would find it hard to believe that he trains any harder than Mayweather. I also think that Floyd, like Ali and Leonard before him, is a guy who has the image of a boxer and a personality first but like those two guys did countless times, I think when the going gets tough, Floyd will respond like a champion. If Hatton thinks he is just going to bully Floyd with no resistance coming back at him then I think he will be terribly mistaken.

I also think that the majority of people that count all the ways that Hatton will win this fight also happen to be people who do not personally like Floyd and their opinions are more wishful thinking than anything. As much as I think Floyd is very, very immature in his bragging about how much money he has, as much as I think his friend Leonard Ellerbee talks way too much trash for a guy who never fought before and doesn't fight, and as much as I think Floyd probably will not be remembered -for a variety of reasons- as a true and revered legend of the game many years after his final fight like Leonard and Ali are now, I do think he is far and away the elite of today and everything in this equation points to his winning December 8 in a very convincing performance.

Putting it another way, the night before James Toney and Roy Jones fought out in Las Vegas back in 1994 Roy's lawyer asked me for my honest opinion and I told him this: "James Toney is a very good, maybe even a great, fighter but all the things that make him great will never come into play -stylistically- against a Roy Jones."

Substitute the names Mayweather and Hatton and you have my same prognosis for December 8.  - JOHN "ICEMAN" SCULLY, trainer/retired boxer


Easy Night for P.B.F.  Hatton looks sloppy trying for KO. Mayweather wins 12 UD   - KENNY BARRETT, gym owner/trainer, www.barrettboxing.com


Mayweather by decision.  Floyd's much too fast for Hatton and possesses superior boxing skills.  Since he doesn't punch hard enough to crack an egg, he'll simply out box the English challenger, much like he did against Oscar de la Hoya, but probably a little easier since Oscar is a better boxer than Ricky. - ED KAPLAN, 560 WQAM Sports Radio, Show Host, Miami, Florida


Mayweather by unanimous decision or late round TKO 11 - DAMON FELDMAN, promoter


Who I want to win: Hatton
Who I think will win: Mayweather by decision.
I don’t see Floyd as having the power to knock Ricky down, let alone KO him. - MELISSA DeVOLENTINE, Publicist, Alfonso Gomez Team


I believe Hatton will end the domination that Floyd has had on opponents... Hatton in a decision... might even knock him out.  - ELMO ADOLPH, boxing referee


Pretty Boy will pitch a shutout against The Hitman – or close to it. Floyd is simply too fast and can box too well to allow the spirited brawler to get close. Hatton may resort to fighting in the grey area of the rules of sanctioned pugilism by using some of his old tricks… but you better believe if Floyd even thinks he was fouled at all, he will make sure that the millions of people watching know about it.

Pretty Boy Floyd Joy Mayweather Jr. by unanimous decision - TERRY LANE, CEO Let's Get It On Promotions


I have to go with Floyd here. Too much talent. But I think Hatton tries to rough him up. He has to if he hopes to have any chance. Could be close early, but PBF pulls away and wins a unanimous decision. - RUSS AMBER, Host TSN In this Corner


 

~For more on Mayweather vs Hatton visit our Exclusive Directory here-

11-27-2007


Brought to you by Saratogamist copyright 2001-2007