PLASTER OF PARIS? WE NEED TO KNOW...

 

By Francisco Guzman

  
 

 

 

 

M~~ Margarito did this to Miguel Cotto ~~

 

 

When Antonio Margarito beat the then undefeated Miguel Cotto, most were blown away. Margarito took some hard shots from Cotto, sometimes getting his head knocked around like a piñata, but he still kept coming. The first sign of trouble for Cotto came in the 2nd round, when Margarito hit him against the ropes, drawing blood from his nose. What became more evident was the way Cotto's face looked with each passing round. By the end of the fight Cotto’s face looked a mess; he was  bleeding from his nose, mouth and by the left cheekbone, below and above his eye.

 

The punishment Cotto took in that fight is the kind that could change a fighter's career, and his life. In the 11th round Cotto took a knee twice because of all the punishment being dealt by Margarito, before uncle/trainer Evangelista Cotto stepped in to throw the towel. It was a terrifying ending, with the broadcasting network showing Cotto’s bloody face, and in the crowd Cotto’s wife holding one of their sons on her lap as they both cried. This fight made Margarito look like he was Predator, Jason and Freddy Krueger put together. He became an instant star. There was talk of him being the next great Mexican fighter in the line of Salvador Sanchez and Julio Cesar Chavez. The way tornadoes tear through towns, Margarito would tear through his opponents. One of the most avoided fighters in boxing was now one of the most dangerous.

 

In comes Shane Mosley, a fighter who had lost a close but decisive fight against Cotto. After Shane's win over Mayorga, he asked to take on Margarito, to the surprise of many. Most boxing experts felt that if Shane had trouble with Cotto, taking on Margarito would be a hard pill to swallow.  Mosley was coming off the BALCO debacle, having admitted  to taking steroids and also freshly divorced from his then wife Jen. There was a lot riding on Shane putting himself back in the mix as the top welterweight in the division.

 

Larry Merchant stated during the telecast that an illegal hard plastic shell had been found in Margarito's hand wraps. Jim Lampley added, “It has been reported by some who saw it." That illegal substance allegedly found in Margarito's hand wraps was wet and it was hardening. Lampley went on to speak of a fight that happened nearly a hundred years ago, between Jack Dempsey and Jess Willard, where Dempsey was said to have had loaded gloves, the substance loading the gloves was called “plaster of Paris.”

 

The comment stuck out like a sore dumb. There was also something different about Margarito's punches. They were not having the same effect on Shane as they did on Cotto. Shane also did something that Cotto didn’t do; he clinched to keep Margarito from punching. He worked Margarito's body, slowly breaking him down and eventually knocking him down in the 7th round and knocking him  out in the 8th. Margarito went from looking like a tornado to looking like a tumbleweed.

 

The controversy was not over. Again the whole hand wrap issue was mentioned. Jim Lampley reported, “Before the fight, Nazim Richardson, Shane Mosley’s trainer was in Antonio Margarito’s dressing room to see his hands being wrapped and he pointed out to California Athletic Commission officials that he saw something being put into the hand wrap, something which was illegal and did not belong there. California Athletic Commission officials confirmed that they found within Antonio’s Margarito hand wraps something that they are calling a hard plastic shell and they removed it from the hand wraps.”

 

“Now... we all remember how those thudding blows in the Las Vegas beat down of Miguel Cotto last July," said Lampley. "There weren’t any thudding blows tonight. Did Margarito just cast a large shadow over his giant victory over Cotto last summer?"

 

That dark shadow grew larger days after the news broke out. First Margarito and his trainer were suspended and then issued a one year revocation. The question surfaced whether they had done this before, especially in his fight against Cotto. During their hearing the evidence was not present. No testing to see what was in the hard substance, leaving much room for rumors and speculation. As boxing fans, and in the interest of all concerned and the integrity of the sport, don't you think we need to know? It's almost like finding a gun but not knowing if it is loaded or not.

 

Other questions surfaced whether or not Cotto could come back from such a devastating loss. The kind of loss that takes something out of a fighter. One must consider that if Margarito's gloves were loaded then Cotto can't be blamed for bending, not under those circumstances. After all, who would one to fight someone wearing brass knuckles?

 

Weeks prior to his fight with Michael Jennings, Cotto was frequently asked about the controversy surrounding Margarito . Sometimes he would not answer, giving the indication that he was not concerned about it. Other times he would express his anger. “All I know is that when everybody gets their hands wrapped, we know what’s in them. Every boxer knows if there is something different in their hands or not. And I think as a fighter, you would know if you have anything in there or not,” said Cotto of Margarito's claim that he did not know anything about what was in his hand wraps.

Cotto also told reporters in Puerto Rico that he is “very angry with Top Rank,” adding that once his contract is up he may no longer be with the company.  Cotto also compared the Margarito-Capetillo case to another loaded gloves case from 1983, which involved trainer Panama Lewis and Luis Resto. Lewis had reportedly pulled about two ounces of padding out of Resto’s gloves and loaded his wraps for a fight against Billy Collins Jr. A fight with similarities, as Collins was undefeated like Cotto.  By the end of the fight Collins' face, like Cotto’s, was battered and bruised.  It was ironic that Resto was not considered a big puncher, yet Resto brutally beat Collins that night.

From the beating he took Collins suffered a torn iris and permanently blurred vision, ending his boxing career. Suffering psychological  depression from not being able to fight anymore Collins began drinking.  A year after his fight with Resto, Collins crashed his car into a culvert, killing himself instantly. Lewis and Resto went on trial in 1986 and were found guilty of assault, criminal possession of a weapon and conspiracy. They each served two-and-a-half years in prison and were banned from boxing for life.

The truth is that a fighter puts himself at risk when he steps in through the ring ropes. Fighters have died and suffered debilitating injuries in the ring and something like loaded gloves makes that risk so much greater.

Back to Margarito and his trainer -a one year revocation is light for what ia at stake. The truth is that loading your gloves is a crime, as it endangers the life of an athlete. It’s understandable that a fighter like Cotto, who doesn’t know how to lose, and hears something like gloves being loaded has to be angry and question whether or not there was some kind of foul play involved.

 

Miguel’s knockout win over Michael Jennings this past Saturday night to capture the vacant WBO welterweight title was nothing more than a confidence builder. Jennings was not the opponent to let us know how much Cotto has left. Only time will tell.

 

Despite the rumors, all we know is that there was a hard substance in Antonio Margarito's wraps. Everybody from trainer Nazim Richardson, the assigned commission and its inspectors, Shane’s lawyer and Shane Mosley himself saw what was in those wraps.  Margarito’s trainer has also gone on record to say that he accidentally put this substance in Antonio’s hand wraps, so there was foul play. The problem is that we don’t know what was in the wraps. There has yet to be a conclusion to the situation, we need to know, was there "plaster of Paris?"

 

 

 

~Editor's Note - For more on plaster of Paris click here~

 

 

2-26-2009

 

 

 

 

 

Brought to you by Saratogamist copyright 2001-2009