HBO Saturday Special a dual thriller: Williams nips Martinez, Arreola halts Minto

By George Elsasser

 

 

 

                                                                        

 
 

Last nite’s twin-bill over HBO from the boardwalk of bag ladies, at Atlantic City, N.J., had those in attendance out of its seats in a dual action packed thriller that topped expectations.

Heavyweights Cristobal Arreola and Brian Minto opened festivities in what was to be, on paper, a can’t miss natural to return Arreola to contender/prospect levels after the disastrous Vitali Klitschko spanking.

Arreola arrives at 6’4 -263 lbs - also younger than Minto at 28 to 34. Minto tipped the scales at 218 lbs on 5’11 frame - and all went as expected - well, sort of, if the end result is seen as the rest of the story. 

Opening stanza pretty much sums up the inevitable - a Minto big right hand lands flush on the Arreola kisser without so much as a Arreola blink who continues in role of aggressor

Round two an action stanza with both finding the mark - is clear both  fighters checked defense at the front desk when arriving - then candle three and is clear to all watching, Arreola too big, and Minto too brave.

Round four sees Minto in attempt to capture some ground - goes on the offense - both toss right hands with Minto’s a hair short as he runs smack into a Arreola bomb and is down.

No sooner on his feet the Butler “Beast” engages the Arreola “Nightmare” in a furious exchange that sees Arreola closing the show via TKO at 2:40 mark of the round. 

Post Scripts: Chris Arreola (28-1, 25 KOs) ~ age 28 - the quest of becoming the first Mexican heavyweight champion has been resurrected - but first a caution:  a) avoid IBF; WBO; WBC champions that carry surname Klitschko. Too slow, too predictable, lacking in defense.
b) When ready, the WBA the better choice for that second title attempt.
                    Brian Minto (34-3, 21 KOs) ~ age 34 - showed true grit but on wrong side of the slope. Can still fill the joints at the small club circuit of choice. 

                     Referee Eddie Cotton had himself a good outing - let the brawlers brawl - stopped it at the right time.

……………………………….................................................................     
 
Williams - Martinez barn-burner closes on sour note
  
The feature attraction non-title light middleweight battle opened with WBO shareholder Paul Williams tossing aside the height (6’ 1") advantage over 5’ 10" WBC shareholder Martinez and quickly bringing the action to the inside

Early in the opening candle and Martinez is down courtesy of a Williams left hand -  then, the Argentine is no sooner on his feet he surprises Williams with a counter right-hook that drops the favorite

From that point on the exchanges are hot and heavy- Williams continues role of aggressor after cut left eyelid. My unofficial had it all square after six stanzas.

It continued in coin-flip fashion with Williams the busier and Martinez landing the cleaner, harder punches - with no knockdowns over the backside there was little room to lean to either fighter.

Williams appeared the fresher over the proverbial championship rounds of 10-11-12, but Martinez had enough in the tank to hold his own in the final tallies.

Then came the official scoring: Julie Lederman had it even at 114-114; Lynne Carter saw it Williams 115-113: Pierre Benoist agreed Williams to the off-beat tune of 119-110.

My unofficial saw it all square at 114-114 in points and six -six under the archaic round by round system.

Post Scripts: Paul Williams (38-1, 27 KOs) ~ age 28 - has size and southpaw advantage going for him. Brain trust must convince him to use the birth-given physical advantages if stepping up to the next rung. Battling in the trenches is not for fighters carrying “praying mantis”  physique. He’s got heart, decent chin and a long reach to set up the power punches.

                       Sergio Martinez (44-2-2, 24 KOs) ~ age 34 - Still has quickness and uses the right hook off the southpaw stance along with power left hand. Return could be in the working, but more than a few other jr. middles out there for him after the HBO exposure. 

Final thoughts: With all the furor over French judge Pierre Benoist scoring the fight as lopsided as he did (119-110 - and 11-1 in rounds) I think there’s something missing in the translation of most fans and assorted Maxie-boy Kellerman, Lamphead, etc.
                       Boxing is competed under a round by round scoring method, whether it be via points or number of rounds won. With that in mind it is conceivable one fighter could well be seen losing each stanza albeit a coin-flip round after round.
                       I don’t feel Benoist qualifies for a tar & feathering without proof he bet the mortgage on Williams.  
                              
GEL 

 

==Become a  BRC friend in Facebook==

For Fight Recaps between January and May 2009, click here...  Fight Recaps Part I (January-May 2009)

For Fight Recaps starting June 2009, click here...  Fight Recaps Part II (June-December 2009)

 

Questions? Comments? Post them in BRC's new Message Board...

 

 

 

12-5-2009

 

 

Brought to you by Saratogamist copyright 2001-2009